Gen AI

How to avoid an AI-pocalypse

John Tang, photo Ivar Pel/DUB

We are now at the pointy end of the academic year when students are madly preparing for exams and writing their theses. As teachers, we recognize the importance of assessment and at the same time have a foreboding sense of what we will be grading. Will the work show sufficient mastery of the course? Did we prepare the students well enough to cross the finish line, and if not, was there more that we could have done?

This question is not new, but in recent years education has fundamentally and radically changed. Of course, I am talking about GenAI and how, while its effects may not yet be seen in the economy at large, our sector is at the thin edge of the wedge that may upend the world as we know it. 

If students are perplexed with how to use (or not) GenAI responsibly, us educators are similarly in this liminal space of how to accommodate this technology. Some of my colleagues have developed a GenAI reflection tool that enables lecturers to know whether GenAI can be aligned with their course learning objectives. But even it concludes that there is no way to know whether GenAI poses a problem for specific assessment types. And at the end of the day, our concern is how this technology affects student learning.

In a recent survey among history students of the study association UHSK, about 68 percent (8 out of 25 students) indicated that they used GenAI. The most common ways were to summarize readings (hello, CliffNotes?), to search for information, and to write (part) of their assignments. All of these approaches are shortcuts, which I completely understand given the demands on time, but the question is whether they promote learning.

In my course introducing students to historical research, I provide guidelines on what I consider appropriate and inappropriate uses of GenAI: proofreading, reference checking, summarizing own writing, and brainstorming are fine; writing text and using summaries instead of reading the material itself are not. Furthermore, I required the students to document which GenAI software and prompts that they used. 

In other words, I encouraged my students to be proactive and responsible users, and not just passive learners. What I found striking is that while 75 percent of UHSK survey respondents did not want GenAI integrated into the curriculum (somewhat ironic given how many of them use it), all five of my students responding to the Caracal evaluation found its integration in our course to be moderately or very useful.

This disconnect mirrors new research about whether GenAI helps or hinders the learning process. If we consider GenAI as part of digital literacy and tailor its use by discipline, then the technology can personalize the learning process and help strengthen specific areas that students are weaker in. If it is used in an ad hoc, unstructured way or to offload cognitively challenging tasks, then students become apprehensive about GenAI affecting their creativity and critical thinking skills. The point is about fitting the technology's strengths and weaknesses to the educational profile and needs of students; if these are taken into account, GenAI does not have to be the bugbear that destroys the value of learning.

So what do we as teachers make of this? Yes, we worry that students will write term papers that are basically regurgitated ChatGPT/Claude/Gemini output. And yes, we are adapting our assessment methods: fewer papers, more intermediate drafts, real-time internet-limited written exams (e.g., Remindo), even oral ones. But do I anticipate a wholesale meltdown of our educational model? No, not really. That is because we as teachers and students can make choices in how we use the technologies around us. Coupled with the fact that the world will not stop changing just because we want it to or are afraid of the changes, it seems sensible not to fight GenAI, but to join it on our own terms.

On Staff's Viewpoint, UU's employees share their views with the UU community. The economic historian John Tang is one of the columnists invited for this space. You can also read students' perspectives on Students' Viewpoint and click here to check out students and staff's columns in Dutch.

Login to comment

Comments

We appreciate relevant and respectful responses. Responding to DUB can be done by logging into the site. You can do so by creating a DUB account or by using your Solis ID. Comments that do not comply with our game rules will be deleted. Please read our response policy before responding.

Advertisement